Karin and Brandilee, only you can fully assess the situation. But the marriage really comes down to a litmus test: are you better off with him, or without him? In both of your situations, it sounds to me as if your marriages aren’t passing the litmus test.
I was divorced by my husband (who was not abusive at all). I was lucky enough to have my brother, 500 miles away, willing to have me move into their basement long enough to get a car, find a job and get my own place.
Some time after that, I relocated 300 miles away with a boyfriend. I didn’t have a car. Big mistake! I eventually found temp work I could get to on public transportation, but it was a city not well designed for public transit. He got to be more and more controlling, and more and more emotionally abusive. I finally left, with only a week of planning. My brother, his wife, and my best friend brought a truck, a trailer, and a tiny car to move me, what little furniture & books I had, and my cats. Again moved into my brother’s basement for a short period, got transportation and a job, then found an apartment for me and my cats.
It *can* be done. You *can* get out. Part of the insidious nature of controlling & emotionally abusive behavior is convincing the person that they can’t change the situation, that they’re helpless, hopeless, and worthless. You need to do what you need to do to preserve your own self-respect, because it’s apparent that he’s damaging your self-esteem.
It will not be easy; it will not be fun. But eventually you will find yourself in a much more content frame of mind, not being second-guessed, not being interrogated, not having to deal with his insecurities and issues.
You can do it. You are worth it.
You have your whole life ahead of you. Do you want to spend it struggling to change someone who doesn’t want to change?